7 Ways of Comparing Above Ground vs Underground Cisterns For Your Climate

When it comes to rainwater harvesting, choosing between above ground and underground cisterns is a critical decision that affects your system’s efficiency, cost, and maintenance needs. Above ground cisterns offer visibility, easier installation, and typically lower upfront costs, while underground systems provide space-saving benefits and protection from freezing temperatures. Your choice ultimately depends on your specific property constraints, climate conditions, budget considerations, and aesthetic preferences.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Understanding Cistern Systems: Above Ground vs Underground Options

Cistern systems come in two primary configurations: above ground and underground installations. Each option has distinct characteristics that affect performance, maintenance, and suitability for different properties. Above ground cisterns sit on a stable foundation exposed to the elements, while underground systems are buried beneath the soil surface. Your choice impacts everything from water quality to installation complexity. When selecting between these options, you’ll need to consider factors like available space, climate conditions, budget constraints, and local regulations. Both systems effectively collect and store rainwater but differ significantly in their installation requirements, ongoing maintenance needs, and visual impact on your property.

Cost Comparison: Installation and Long-term Expenses

When deciding between above ground and underground cisterns, understanding the complete financial picture is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your budget and long-term goals.

Initial Investment Requirements

Above ground cisterns typically cost $0.50-$2 per gallon of capacity, making them substantially more affordable upfront than underground options. Installation requires minimal excavation—usually just a level concrete pad ($200-$500). DIY installation is possible with basic tools and knowledge, saving $500-$1,500 in professional labor costs. For a 2,500-gallon system, expect to spend $1,250-$5,000 total for materials and basic setup.

Underground cisterns demand higher initial investment at $1.50-$4 per gallon plus significant excavation costs ($1,000-$3,000). Professional installation is almost always necessary, adding $2,000-$5,000 to your budget. A comparable 2,500-gallon underground system typically costs $5,750-$15,000 total—often triple the price of above ground options.

Maintenance Cost Differences

Above ground cisterns generally require more frequent maintenance due to exposure to elements. Expect annual costs of $100-$300 for UV-protection treatments, weatherproofing, and pipe insulation in cold climates. Systems typically last 15-20 years before needing replacement, with tanks deteriorating faster from sun exposure and temperature fluctuations.

Underground systems benefit from soil insulation, reducing maintenance needs to $50-$150 annually. However, when issues occur, repair costs are substantially higher due to excavation requirements ($500-$1,500 per service). The lifespan advantage is significant—properly installed underground cisterns often last 25-50 years, effectively halving your long-term replacement costs despite the higher initial investment.

Space Considerations: Visibility and Property Footprint

Aesthetic Impact on Your Property

Above ground cisterns occupy visible space on your property and can impact your landscape’s appearance. You’ll see these tanks from windows and outdoor areas, potentially affecting curb appeal and property value. While some modern cisterns feature attractive designs and can be incorporated into landscaping, others might appear utilitarian. Underground cisterns offer complete visual concealment, preserving your property’s aesthetics and maintaining the natural look of your landscape.

Maximizing Available Land

Underground cisterns free up valuable surface space, allowing you to utilize your land for gardens, patios, or parking areas. You can even install them under driveways or lawns, maximizing your property’s functional footprint. Above ground systems, while space-efficient compared to ponds, still claim usable square footage on your property. For smaller lots or densely developed areas, underground systems provide significant space advantages, though they require initial excavation that temporarily disrupts larger areas during installation.

Climate Adaptability: Temperature and Weather Protection

Freeze Protection Capabilities

Underground cisterns offer superior freeze protection since soil acts as natural insulation. Buried below the frost line (typically 4-6 feet deep), these systems maintain water above freezing even in harsh winters. Above ground cisterns, however, require additional insulation methods like heat tape, insulated covers, or housing structures to prevent freezing. Without proper protection, above ground systems in cold climates risk pipe damage and water accessibility issues during winter months.

Heat Resistance Features

Underground cisterns naturally maintain cooler water temperatures due to consistent soil temperatures, generally staying between 50-60°F year-round regardless of surface conditions. This natural cooling prevents algae growth and maintains water quality during hot summers. Above ground systems, especially plastic or metal tanks, can experience significant heating in direct sunlight, potentially reaching 80-90°F. This warming increases evaporation rates and may necessitate additional filtration or treatment to maintain water quality during summer months.

Durability Factors: Lifespan and Material Considerations

Material Options for Each Type

Above ground cisterns typically come in plastic, fiberglass, steel, or concrete varieties. Plastic tanks offer affordability and lightweight installation but can degrade from UV exposure. Fiberglass provides better durability while metal options like galvanized steel offer strength but may rust over time. Underground cisterns are commonly constructed from concrete, fiberglass-reinforced plastic (FRP), or high-density polyethylene (HDPE) designed specifically to withstand soil pressure and prevent root intrusion.

Expected Longevity Comparison

Underground cisterns generally outlast their above ground counterparts by a significant margin. Properly installed concrete underground systems can last 50+ years, while fiberglass and HDPE underground tanks typically provide 30-40 years of service. Above ground cisterns have shorter lifespans, with plastic tanks lasting 10-15 years, metal options 15-20 years, and fiberglass versions reaching 20-25 years. The extended longevity of underground systems stems from their protection from UV radiation, temperature fluctuations, and physical damage.

Accessibility: Maintenance and Repair Convenience

Inspection Requirements

Above ground cisterns offer straightforward inspection access, allowing you to easily monitor water levels, check for cracks, or assess water quality with minimal effort. You’ll typically need only a ladder and flashlight to conduct thorough inspections every 3-6 months. In contrast, underground cisterns require specialized access points or manholes for inspection, often necessitating confined space training and equipment for proper assessment. Some jurisdictions also mandate professional inspections for buried water storage systems every 1-2 years.

Repair Accessibility Challenges

When repairs are needed, above ground cisterns present fewer obstacles—components are readily visible and accessible without excavation. You can typically complete minor repairs yourself using standard tools and parts available at hardware stores. Underground cisterns pose significant challenges when problems arise, often requiring professional excavation equipment that can cost $1,000-$3,000 per repair event. Limited access points may necessitate specialized confined space equipment, and locating exact problem areas beneath the surface frequently demands professional assessment.

Water Quality: Storage Environment Effects

Temperature Regulation Impact

Underground cisterns maintain consistent water temperatures year-round, typically between 50-60°F, which inhibits bacteria growth and preserves water quality. This natural temperature regulation occurs because soil acts as an insulator, preventing rapid temperature fluctuations that can degrade water quality. Above ground cisterns, however, experience wider temperature swings—from freezing in winter to potentially reaching 80-90°F in summer—making them more susceptible to bacterial proliferation and algae growth without additional treatment.

Light Exposure Considerations

Underground cisterns provide complete protection from sunlight, eliminating photosynthesis-driven algae growth that can contaminate stored water. This darkness prevents the formation of biofilms and limits microbial activity that thrives in sunlit environments. Above ground cisterns, especially transparent or translucent models, allow light penetration that can stimulate algae blooms and accelerate bacterial growth, often requiring additional filtration, opaque materials, or regular cleaning to maintain water quality standards.

Installation Complexity: DIY Potential vs Professional Requirements

Permit Requirements by Type

Above ground cisterns typically require simpler permits than their underground counterparts. Many jurisdictions classify above ground installations as standard plumbing projects, requiring only basic permits costing $50-$200. Underground cisterns often trigger additional permit requirements including soil testing, engineered drawings, and excavation approval, potentially costing $300-$800. Local health departments may also require specific documentation for both systems when used for potable water applications.

Equipment and Expertise Needed

Installing above ground cisterns generally requires basic tools like wrenches, pipe cutters, and a level—equipment most homeowners already own. The process typically takes 1-2 days for a moderately handy person. Underground installations demand specialized equipment including excavators, compactors, and heavy-duty lifting machinery. These projects usually require professional contractors with expertise in excavation, plumbing, and drainage systems, often taking 3-5 days to complete and costing significantly more due to labor complexity.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Cistern for Your Specific Needs

The decision between above ground and underground cisterns ultimately depends on your unique circumstances. Above ground systems offer affordability and accessibility while underground options provide space efficiency and longevity.

Consider your climate carefully—underground cisterns excel in extreme temperatures while above ground options shine in moderate climates with proper preparation. Your budget will significantly impact your choice with underground systems requiring higher upfront investment but potentially offering better long-term value.

Remember to factor in available space aesthetic preferences maintenance requirements and local regulations. The perfect cistern system balances these considerations against your property’s specific constraints.

Whichever option you choose a well-planned rainwater harvesting system represents a sustainable investment in both your property and environmental stewardship.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between above ground and underground cisterns?

Above ground cisterns are visible, easier to install, and generally less expensive upfront, typically costing $0.50-$2 per gallon. Underground cisterns save space, are concealed from view, protect against freezing, and have longer lifespans (25-50 years vs. 15-20 years for above ground), but cost more initially ($1.50-$4 per gallon) due to excavation requirements and professional installation.

How do installation costs compare between the two cistern types?

Above ground cisterns cost less to install, with a 2,500-gallon system ranging from $1,250-$5,000. They can often be installed by homeowners in 1-2 days with basic tools. Underground cisterns require a higher investment of $5,750-$15,000 for a similar system due to excavation costs and professional installation, which typically takes 3-5 days and requires specialized equipment.

Which type of cistern is better for cold climates?

Underground cisterns offer superior freeze protection as they’re buried below the frost line, keeping water above freezing even in harsh winters. Above ground cisterns require additional insulation methods to prevent freezing, which can lead to pipe damage and accessibility issues in cold climates. For areas with severe winters, underground systems are generally the better choice.

How do maintenance requirements differ between cistern types?

Above ground cisterns have higher annual maintenance costs ($100-$300) but offer easier access for inspection and repairs without excavation. Underground cisterns have lower annual costs ($50-$150) but require specialized access points for inspection, professional assessments every 1-2 years, and potentially costly excavation when repairs are needed.

Which cistern type provides better water quality?

Underground cisterns maintain more consistent water temperatures (50-60°F), inhibiting bacteria growth and algae formation due to complete protection from sunlight and the insulating properties of soil. Above ground cisterns experience wider temperature fluctuations and sunlight exposure, making them more susceptible to bacterial proliferation and algae growth, often requiring additional filtration and regular cleaning.

How do space considerations affect cistern choice?

Underground cisterns maximize usable land by allowing for gardens, patios, or parking areas above them, making them ideal for smaller lots or densely developed areas. Above ground cisterns occupy visible space and may affect curb appeal and property value, though some modern designs can blend into landscaping. Space-constrained properties generally benefit more from underground systems.

What materials are commonly used for each cistern type?

Above ground cisterns typically come in plastic (affordable but UV-sensitive), fiberglass (more durable), steel, or concrete. Underground cisterns are commonly made from concrete (50+ year lifespan), fiberglass-reinforced plastic (FRP), or high-density polyethylene (HDPE) designed to withstand soil pressure and prevent root intrusion, with lifespans of 30-40 years for fiberglass and HDPE options.

How complex is the installation process for each cistern type?

Above ground cisterns require simpler permits and can often be installed by homeowners with basic tools in 1-2 days. Underground cisterns often need additional permits (soil testing, excavation approval) and require specialized equipment and professional contractors for installation, typically taking 3-5 days and resulting in higher labor costs and initial property disruption.