7 Best Crowbars for Pulling Out Broken Posts That Old Farmers Swear By

Struggling with stubborn, broken posts that refuse to budge? A quality crowbar can be your best ally for these frustrating extraction jobs, providing the leverage and strength needed to pull out even the most deeply embedded posts.

Today we’ll explore the top 7 crowbars specifically designed for post removal, comparing their durability, leverage capabilities, and ergonomic features. You’ll discover options ranging from heavy-duty steel models for commercial use to lighter, more maneuverable versions perfect for DIY projects around your property.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Understanding Why a Quality Crowbar Matters for Post Removal

A quality crowbar is your most reliable ally when facing stubborn broken posts. Unlike standard pry bars, specialized post removal crowbars offer superior leverage capabilities that significantly reduce the physical effort required. The difference between a high-quality tool and a subpar alternative becomes immediately apparent when you’re wrestling with deeply embedded posts.

Material construction directly impacts performance and longevity. Premium crowbars made from forged steel resist bending and breaking under extreme pressure, while lower-quality options can fail at critical moments. The best crowbars feature hardened tips that bite effectively into wood or concrete, providing the secure grip needed for controlled extraction.

Ergonomic design elements like non-slip handles and strategic weight distribution prevent hand fatigue and injury during extended use. When removing multiple posts, these features transform from mere conveniences into essential safety components. The investment in a quality crowbar ultimately saves you time, physical strain, and potential damage to surrounding structures during the removal process.

7 Best Crowbars for Pulling Out Broken Posts

Here are the top-rated crowbars specifically designed for efficiently removing broken posts, each offering unique features to tackle this challenging task.

Stanley FatMax Fubar Utility Bar

The Stanley FatMax Fubar combines versatility with industrial-grade durability. Its dual-ended design features a curved end for powerful prying and a straight end for nail extraction, making it perfect for broken post removal. The forged steel construction withstands extreme leverage, while the textured grip prevents slipping during intense pulling actions.

Estwing Pro-Claw Nail Puller

Estwing’s Pro-Claw excels at broken post extraction despite its primary nail-pulling design. The precisely curved claw generates exceptional leverage with minimal effort, allowing you to grip and gradually free stubborn posts. Made from solid American steel with Estwing’s signature blue finish, it delivers professional-grade durability in a compact package.

Vaughan & Bushnell SuperBar

The Vaughan & Bushnell SuperBar offers outstanding strength-to-weight efficiency for post removal. Its strategically designed rocker head provides maximum leverage when positioned correctly against broken posts. The spring steel construction flexes slightly without breaking, distributing force evenly while the precision-ground ends grip securely against post remnants.

Crescent 56″ Heavy Duty Wrecking Bar

Crescent’s 56″ Wrecking Bar delivers unmatched leverage for deeply embedded posts. The extended length creates a mechanical advantage that multiplies your force input, making it ideal for extracting posts set in concrete. The hexagonal shaft prevents rolling while the reinforced striking cap allows for hammer assistance during difficult extractions.

DeWalt Carbon Steel Flat Pry Bar

DeWalt’s Carbon Steel Flat Pry Bar features a slim, wedge-shaped profile that slides easily beneath broken posts. The hardened carbon steel construction resists bending even under extreme pressure, while the powder-coated finish prevents rust in outdoor environments. Its flat design excels at creating initial separation between posts and surrounding soil.

Bully Tools Farm and Ranch Post Puller

The Bully Tools Post Puller is purpose-built specifically for post extraction challenges. Its specialized jaw design wraps securely around posts of various diameters, providing consistent grip during the entire removal process. The American-made fiberglass handle reduces weight while maintaining strength, and the triple-wall construction prevents snapping under load.

Fiskars IsoCore 36″ Wrecking Bar

Fiskars’ IsoCore Wrecking Bar incorporates patented shock-absorbing technology that reduces hand strain by 70%. The 36″ length provides excellent leverage while the dual-material handle prevents slipping in wet conditions. The precision-milled ends bite efficiently into wooden posts, while the structural design distributes force evenly to prevent bending during heavy extraction work.

Key Features to Look for in a Post-Removal Crowbar

Finding the right crowbar for removing broken posts can make a difficult job much easier. The best tools combine leverage, durability, comfort, and appropriate weight for effective extraction.

Leverage Capacity

Your crowbar’s leverage capability is crucial for successful post removal. Look for models with handles at least 46 inches long to generate maximum force with minimal effort. A well-designed fulcrum point transfers your strength efficiently, allowing you to loosen even stubbornly embedded posts. The Wrecking Claw 46-in Steel Wrecking bar exemplifies this with its 4.6-star rating, providing the mechanical advantage needed to tackle the toughest extraction jobs.

Material Durability

High-carbon steel crowbars deliver superior performance and longevity when removing posts. This material withstands extreme pressure without bending or breaking, even when prying against concrete footings or hard-packed soil. Premium options like the Kobalt High Carbon Steel Wrecking Bar and Estwing Steel Wrecking Bar (both rated 4.8 stars) maintain their integrity through repeated use in challenging conditions, making them wise investments for multiple projects.

Grip Comfort

Ergonomic handles prevent slippage and reduce hand fatigue during strenuous post removal. Look for crowbars with textured, cushioned, or contoured grips that provide secure control when applying significant force. The Estwing Steel Moulding Pry Bar features a comfortable grip design that lets you maintain precise control throughout the extraction process. This comfort factor becomes especially important during extended use or when removing multiple posts in succession.

Weight Considerations

A crowbar weighing approximately 20 pounds offers ideal balance between leveraging power and maneuverability. Heavier bars provide greater force for initial loosening but may cause fatigue during prolonged use. Lighter options like the Kobalt 11-in Metal Moulding pry bar (4.9 rating) offer excellent control for precision work but require more effort for stubborn posts. Choose your tool’s weight based on the specific post size and soil conditions you typically encounter.

Proper Techniques for Removing Posts With a Crowbar

Assessment and Preparation

Before you start removing broken posts, assess the installation method. Determine whether your post is set in soil, concrete footing, or a concrete slab. This initial evaluation helps you choose the right technique and additional tools you might need. Prepare the work area by clearing any obstacles that could interfere with your leverage or movement.

Using the Crowbar Effectively

Positioning your crowbar correctly is crucial for successful post removal. Place the flat end of the bar firmly against the side of the post and gradually wiggle it to create space between the post and surrounding material. Ensure your crowbar is securely positioned to prevent slipping, which could cause injuries or damage the tool.

When applying leverage, position the crowbar under the post once you’ve created enough space. Use your body weight rather than just arm strength by stepping on the bar or using a controlled pushing motion. This technique maximizes the mechanical advantage of your crowbar while minimizing physical strain on your body.

Additional Tools and Techniques

Pair your crowbar with a digging bar or post-hole digger to clear soil around the base. Exposing more of the post’s foundation gives your crowbar better access points and reduces the force needed for extraction. This step is particularly important when dealing with posts in compacted or rocky soil conditions.

For stubborn posts, consider using a farm jack or high lift jack after initial loosening with your crowbar. Position the jack securely at the base of the post and gradually increase the lifting pressure. The combination of horizontal leverage from your crowbar and vertical lifting from the jack creates a comprehensive extraction approach.

When facing posts set in concrete, supplement your crowbar work with a sledgehammer to break away concrete chunks or use a reciprocating saw to cut through difficult sections. These tools help weaken the concrete’s grip, making your crowbar’s leverage more effective at the final extraction stage.

Safety Considerations

Always wear proper safety equipment including heavy-duty gloves, safety glasses, and steel-toed boots when working with crowbars. The significant force used during post removal can cause unexpected movements or material failures.

Maintain a secure stance and grip throughout the process, positioning your body to avoid fall paths if the post suddenly releases. Keep bystanders at a safe distance from your work area, as broken posts or concrete fragments can become projectiles when extracted under pressure.

Maintenance Tips to Extend Your Crowbar’s Lifespan

Cleaning

Regularly clean your crowbar to remove dirt, grime, and potential rust. After each use, wipe down the bar with a dry cloth to remove debris. For stubborn dirt, use a wire brush and mild detergent, then thoroughly dry the tool before storage to prevent moisture damage.

Storage

Store your crowbar in a dry place to maintain its condition and prevent rust formation. Hang it on a tool rack or place it in a storage cabinet away from humid environments. Avoid leaving your crowbar outside or in damp basements where exposure to moisture can accelerate corrosion.

Inspection

Inspect your crowbar regularly for signs of wear such as cracks, bends, or rust spots. Check the tips and edges for damage or deformation that might affect performance. Address minor rust spots immediately with sandpaper and rust inhibitor, and replace the bar if you notice significant structural damage.

Lubrication

Apply a light layer of oil or lubricant to protect your crowbar from rust and corrosion. Focus on the working ends and any moving parts. A thin coat of WD-40 or machine oil applied every few months helps maintain the tool’s integrity, especially if you use it in wet environments.

Proper Use

Use your crowbar correctly to avoid unnecessary damage. Avoid using it as a hammer or applying force at angles it wasn’t designed for. Select the appropriate size crowbar for each job rather than overstressing a smaller tool, and never use extension pipes to increase leverage beyond the tool’s design limits.

Handling

Handle your crowbar with care to prevent accidental drops or impacts. When not in use, place it securely on the ground rather than leaning it against walls where it might fall. For premium tools like the Estwing Steel Wrecking Bar or IRWIN Steel Crowbar, proper handling significantly extends their service life.

Safety Precautions When Using Crowbars for Post Extraction

Preparation Before Starting

Before you tackle that stubborn broken post, proper preparation is essential. Assess the post installation method—whether it’s set in concrete, driven directly into soil, or anchored with hardware—as this determines your approach. Clear a 6-inch deep area around the base of the post to expose more surface area for your crowbar to grip. Remove any compacted soil, rocks, or debris that might interfere with your leverage points or cause your tools to slip unexpectedly.

Safe Handling Techniques

Position your crowbar strategically to maximize leverage while minimizing strain. Place a solid block of wood next to the post to create a fulcrum point—this distributes force more effectively and prevents the crowbar from digging into soft ground. When using a heavy crowbar (approximately 20 pounds), maintain a proper stance with feet shoulder-width apart to prevent back injuries. Avoid forcefully jabbing the crowbar into the post; instead, apply controlled pressure to prevent the wood from splitting suddenly.

Working With Concrete-Set Posts

Concrete-embedded posts require special attention for safe removal. Use a sledgehammer to carefully break away the concrete before attempting to pry the post free. Work methodically around the perimeter of the concrete base rather than striking repeatedly in one spot. Keep your face away from flying concrete chips, and wear impact-resistant safety glasses to protect your eyes from debris. Consider using a farm jack or high lift jack for additional vertical lifting power once the concrete has been sufficiently broken up.

Protective Equipment Requirements

Always wear thick work gloves to protect against splinters and blisters while maintaining a firm grip on your crowbar. Safety glasses are non-negotiable—they shield your eyes from wood fragments, dirt, and concrete debris that commonly fly up during extraction. Steel-toed boots provide crucial foot protection should the post or crowbar fall unexpectedly. Consider wearing a back brace if you’re removing multiple posts to reduce strain during extended periods of leveraging heavy tools.

Monitoring Stability During Extraction

As you begin lifting the post, increase pressure gradually while watching for sudden shifts in stability. Posts can release unexpectedly, causing tools to spring back dangerously. If working on a fence line, secure adjacent posts temporarily to prevent chain-reaction movement that could cause structural collapse. Listen for cracking sounds that indicate the post might break rather than extract cleanly, and adjust your technique accordingly to maintain control of both the post and your crowbar.

Conclusion: Investing in the Right Tool for the Job

Choosing the right crowbar can make all the difference when tackling stubborn broken posts. With options ranging from the versatile Stanley FatMax Fubar to the ergonomic Fiskars IsoCore, you’ll find a tool that matches your specific needs.

Remember that leverage capacity, material quality and ergonomic design are your best allies in this challenging task. The right crowbar not only saves you time and effort but also prevents potential injuries during the extraction process.

By investing in a quality crowbar and following proper techniques, you’ll transform a seemingly impossible task into a manageable project. Your future self will thank you when that next broken post comes out with minimal struggle and maximum efficiency.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best crowbar for removing stubborn posts?

The Stanley FatMax Fubar stands out for its versatility and industrial-grade durability. For maximum leverage, the Crescent 56″ Heavy Duty Wrecking Bar is excellent for deeply embedded posts. The Bully Tools Farm and Ranch Post Puller is specifically designed for post extraction with a consistent grip. Your choice should depend on the specific post removal challenge you’re facing.

How long should a crowbar be for effective post removal?

A crowbar with a handle at least 46 inches long is recommended for maximum leverage when removing posts. Longer crowbars provide better mechanical advantage, requiring less physical effort and reducing strain. The extra length allows you to apply more force to stubborn posts while maintaining better control over the extraction process.

What material makes the best crowbar for post removal?

High-carbon steel crowbars offer superior performance and longevity for post removal tasks. Premium forged steel options provide better durability and resistance to bending compared to lower-quality alternatives. Crowbars with hardened tips maintain their grip capability over time, even when used on difficult extractions involving concrete or deeply embedded posts.

How do you remove a post set in concrete?

First, assess the installation and clear the area around the post. Use a sledgehammer to break up the surrounding concrete if possible. Position your crowbar as low as possible against the post and use a fulcrum for leverage. Apply steady pressure rather than sudden force. For extremely stubborn posts, consider using additional tools like a digging bar or jack to assist the extraction process.

What safety precautions should I take when using a crowbar?

Always wear protective gear including gloves, safety glasses, and steel-toed boots. Maintain a stable stance with feet shoulder-width apart. Never put your body directly in the line of force in case the crowbar slips. Ensure the work area is clear of obstacles and bystanders. Check that the crowbar is in good condition without cracks or damage before use.

How much should a good post removal crowbar weigh?

The ideal weight for a post removal crowbar is around 20 pounds. This provides a good balance between power and maneuverability. Heavier crowbars (25+ pounds) offer more leverage for stubborn posts but can cause fatigue during extended use. Lighter options (15-18 pounds) are more comfortable for prolonged work but may require more effort for difficult extractions.

How do you maintain a crowbar for longevity?

Clean your crowbar after each use to remove dirt and debris. Store it in a dry place to prevent rust and corrosion. Regularly inspect for signs of wear, especially at the prying end. Apply light oil or rust inhibitor to protect the metal surfaces. Avoid using your crowbar for tasks it wasn’t designed for, as this can damage the tool and reduce its effectiveness.

What’s the proper technique for using a crowbar to remove posts?

Position the crowbar as low as possible against the post. Use a solid object as a fulcrum point close to the post for maximum leverage. Push down on the handle rather than pulling up to utilize your body weight efficiently. Apply steady, consistent pressure instead of jerking motions. Rock the post gently in different directions to gradually loosen it before extraction.